A Test for Mike Nutter: Comcast, or Us?

As I have stated before, I am sort of ambivalent towards Mike Nutter. He has made his signature issues a corporate tax cut, and has an ethics reform package that forgets about public financing of campaigns, by far the most effective way to clean up elections and swing power back towards communities. At the same time, he has by all accounts been a pretty good neighborhood organizer, has been listening to his constituents on the Casino issue, and has led the charge to get rid of smoking in bars around the City.

One thing certain BPT-ers don't like is when I ask how much Comcast, or Aetna will get from a BPT cut. I am reminded of my unanswered question, because Comcast and Mike Nutter are back in the news, and we are going to get a small idea of what kind of person Mike Nutter is. I explain below.

In a great column, of which you should read the whole thing, Jeff Gelles notes the following:

In a hearing at 1 p.m., Comcast officials will urge City Council members to allow them to absorb the city's last non-Comcast franchise territory: the west and northwest quadrant now served by Time Warner Cable.

...

The question is: What will Philadelphia get in return?

...

If there's any hope for change, a key player could be Councilman Michael Nutter, who is shepherding Comcast's franchise-transfer application. In the '90s, Nutter took fellow Council members to task for hastily approving those 15-year franchise extensions.

Nutter has said little this time around, though he hopes to finally bring public-access channels to Philadelphia, the largest U.S. city to lack this electronic-age version of a town square.

But it would hardly be a concession for Comcast to provide five public-access channels for the city, or money to build and operate a media center. All city cable franchise agreements have required that since the 1980s, but the city itself has never insisted.

This is not a newsflash to anyone who has gotten a Comcast bill, but they are absolutely sticking it to Philadelphians. Their prices are outrageous, and their refusal to sell Comcast Sportsnet to competitors such as DirecTV, lets them keep on gauging sports-crazed Philadelphia. If Comcast had to offer their channels to all companies, all of us would pay less, each and every day.

So, Councilman Nutter, where do you stand? Are you standing up for Philadelphia? Or are you helping out your buddies at Comcast? The answer is not public access channels, since that is a law that the City should be enforcing anyway. The answer is actual competition, which benefits Philly, and for all those BPT fanactics out there, makes a hell of a lot more economic sense than a monopoly.

Will be interesting to watch how it all plays out. If anyone went to the hearings, let me know.

Decision: Comcast

Ah, the Comcast lovefest on City Council contiued yesterday. They chose Comcast.

Nutter and Council have another chance next week

Yesterday was most certainly a love fest.

It has been 23 yrs since council passed an ordinance mandating cable providers pay for public access but philly is still waiting. This transfer is a chance to hold Comcast accountable but council missed the opportunity yesterday. Negotiations are underway b/w the Philadelphia Community Access Coalition, the City, and Comcast.

Philly Misses Public Access Opportunity.

As for the larger Nutter conversation I am very undecided but he seems better than the rest of the lot as far as next year.

Comcast Expansion

Comcast Growth = new jobs and expansion of economic opporunity in Philadelphia?

sorry Phantom

But even I cannot take what you are shoveling here. This is not about more jobs for Philadephia, since they are not expanding, they are just trading for, and accumulating a total monopoly in Philly, where they can be more efficient as they gouge their customers. Good for their bottom line? Of course. Good for Philly? When I see those savings passed on to consumers, I will be pretty damn suprised.

As Gelles says, we all want Comcast to succeed. But they are making a ton of money from Philly residents. There is no reason Council shouldn't grow a backbone, and get real concessions from them.

Shoveling in Tandem

Lot's of righteous, rhetorical anger coming from your shovel, so I thought I'd throw a bit of my own. I suspect that if we had the facts in front of us - which I don't - we'd both be pretty impressed by the total economic impact that Comcast has in our City in terms of jobs provided, taxes paid, and direct/in-kind donations and services. I'd do a bit less vilifying of our City's premier corporate citizen, but that's just me. I hope that we get a public access channel; that would be great.

vilifying

Really, am I vilfying them? How? By saying they are a monopoly? Isnt that true? By saying they are gouging us? If you look at cable prices before and after government controls were taken off, what happened? Remember the logic that was used to lift controls? Competition was supposed to save all. Yet, what has happened? In the oldest school of monopolies, Comcast has simply controlled content, and made sure that there is not any competition.

See, here is the difference: I understand, and appreciate that Comcast has a big impact in our city. But, unlike you, that doesn't mean I think we should let them do whatever they want. If they raised their rates by 30 dollars next year, which would keep their profits going up, would you be for that? There is a lot of money to be had by controlling the cable wires of Philadelphia, yet we ignore that leverage over and over.

I guess I just expect more. You "hope" and think it would be great if we got a public access channel- something that has been the law for 20 years and just been ignored. Maybe I am just crrrrrazy, but 20 years later, that is no longer a legitimate crumb to throw our way.

Sorry...

...for reviving this ancient thread, but according to this website, Fattah accepted $27,650 from Comcast since 1989. Doesn't make him a bad guy in my view, just thought it's interesting info. http://www.opensecrets.org/politicians/allcontrib.asp?CID=N00001746

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Syndicate content