In case you missed it: on Wednesday, Philadelphians who want to check out just how new Mayor Nutter's "new day" is have a chance to do just that, by asking the city to make sure that Earthlink does not dismantle the 17 million dollar wireless network affixed to Philadelphia's lightpoles. Beth McConnell posted the news release from the Media Mobilizing Project yesterday:
Media Mobilizing Project and local broadband activists are urging Philadelphians to call Mayor Michael Nutter on Wednesday May 21, to demand that the city step in to save the Wireless Philadelphia network and keep digital inclusion as part of it's agenda. Earthlink plans to begin dismantling the $17 million network June 12, after failing to convince either the city or a non-profit to assume ownership.
When: Wednesday, May 21st 9AM-5PM
Phone Number: (215) 686-3000 or (215) 686-2250.
"A new day?" you say? But it was John Street who put Philadelphia on the wireless map by saying that our city would be one of the first, and the biggest of the wireless hotspots in the country. "Out with the old," you might say -- or "I don't know anyone who uses this network anyway, and it's a waste of money."
Well, I'm here to tell you that if Mayor Nutter wants Philadelphians to get online and to enjoy all the benefits that affordable, ubiquitous access can provide, abandoning Wireless Philadelphia is exactly the wrong start. Plus -- Mayor Nutter is letting Earthlink break a contract it made with our city to operate this network for at least ten years. Letting an out-of-state company walk away from a deal to put our city online, just because the deal is inconvenient, sounds a lot more like yesterday than a new day to me, Mayor Nutter.
Mayor Nutter talks about the concerns he has when it comes to the costs of operating a wireless network -- he doesn't want city residents to pay 3 million dollars a year to subsidize this internet service. Fair enough, I guess, but we should remember that we haven't spent anything at all, yet, on installing or operating the network. The investment and the risk here in the Philly market were Earthlink's. After endless debate in City Council and in the court of public opinion, the city decided to choose a wireless network builder that would build and operate a network at its own cost, and build a profit off of the customer base that it would attract. That didn't work out for a bunch of reasons -- but Mayor Street, and now, Mayor Nutter, have their heads screwed on sideways if they think that a city as big and diverse as Philadelphia can break the digital divide without any investment at all.
On top of that -- instead of committing to being an anchor tenant in the network, paying for city accounts and service and taking some responsibility for using it, the city chose to build a quasi-private nonprofit, Wireless Philadelphia, that would somehow figure out how to force Earthlink to provide reliable, cheap internet to folks without computers or experience using them -- while also raising money to subsidize those computers and that training. With dollar signs and technology-minded fame in his eyes, Mayor Street ran forward, promising no cost to the city, and profit to Earthlink -- forgetting that real investment is needed for real digital inclusion.
Greg Goldman and Wireless Philadelphia should be praised for working hard to raise money and to pilot that training, as Earthlink started to shutter its wireless projects nationwide. He should also be congratulated for sticking to his post and his battleground -- he and Wireless Philadelphia seem to be fighting hard to make the city and Earthlink stop their rush to dismantle the $17 million dollar network.
Whether or not we think that wireless is the right way or the wrong way to provide service to thousands of people who otherwise would have to wait hours at the library to get access to blogs like this, we have to face facts -- if we let the city shut the door on Wireless Philadelphia, we're saying that getting our neighbors online doesn't matter. Instead of bowing to Earthlink's tantrum, the Mayor should be fighting to keep the network online while negotiating a real settlement with Earthlink, Wireless Philadelphia, and the dozens of community groups and institutions who want a seat at the table.
For starters: Earthlink, breaking its contract to serve the city for at least ten years? The Mayor and the City Solicitor need to keep our wireless equipment on our poles and Earthlink's service running, at least for the time being. Next: Earthlink, suing in federal court to keep their contract-breaking liabilities to $1 million dollars or less? If we decide to let Earthlink go, we need a compensation package and a real deal that puts the city on its next steps towards real digital inclusion.
And that's the real point. When it comes to folks and their basic human right to communicate, the technology is a lot less important than all of us coming together to decide what we need and to implement it. The municipal wireless negotiations were notorious for cutting out immigrant communities, independent media makers, and neighborhoods that Comcast and Verizon never visited with cable modems or DSL. And, with no wireless network or organized base of community members clamoring loudly for digital inclusion, Comcast and Verizon will feel well within their rights to smack down any other attempt at the city fighting to serve our community with a network that it owns. Remember: Verizon got the legislature to pass a law keeping municipally-controlled broadband and communications out of every other city in the state back in 2004. Verizon got the right to veto any other community and its plans -- and Rendell signed it.
We got a pass because of Wireless Philly, because we fought to make the decision ourselves -- and I hope we all intend to fight for our right to serve our city with communications any way we damn well please.
Starting with our calls to the Mayor tomorrow, and the Media Mobilizing Project's wireless forum on June 3rd at Temple, we can start fighting to make sure that Philadelphia, and the communications companies who profit here, provide us with communications that are worthy of our great city.
Recent comments
5 hours 19 min ago
5 hours 51 min ago
6 hours 37 min ago
8 hours 9 min ago
19 hours 31 min ago
1 day 1 hour ago
1 day 1 hour ago
1 day 1 hour ago
1 day 5 hours ago
1 day 5 hours ago