- 'An End to the Southern Strategy, But No Post-Racial America' says David Love
- "A Question of Place": An essay on the power of community
- Just Equally Speaking….
- Eagles owe Philadelphia the 8 million it needs to keep libraries open
- who would like to see Verizon offer cable TV in Phila?
- Council Committee Passed the Freeze
- Carol Campbell Passes Away
- My first trip to the public library
- Fight digital exclusion
- What if half of Philadelphia didn't have roads?
Councilmembers Green and Greenlee Announce Legislation That Would Mandate Hands-Free Cellular Devices While Driving
PHILADELPHIA, PA – At-Large Councilmembers Bill Green and Bill Greenlee today announced legislation that would require Philadelphia drivers to put down their cell phones when stepping behind the wheel.
“A distracted driver is a dangerous driver,” observed Councilman Bill Greenlee. “Experience shows that a driver using a cell phone to dial a number or to send a text message is not giving his or her full attention to the road and that puts us all at risk – drivers, bikers and pedestrians alike.”
Studies confirm that drivers who use cell phones while driving are more distracted than those who do not. One study found that the distraction from mobile-phone usage makes drivers as accident-prone as having a blood-alcohol level of .08%, the legal limit for drunken driving (“A Comparison of the Cell Phone Driver and the Drunk Driver,” David L. Strayer, Frank A. Drews and Dennis J. Crouch, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah). The mere act of dialing a cell phone increases the risk of accident by 180% (“Dialing While Fishtailing: How Mobile Phones, Hands-Free Laws, and Driving Conditions Interact to Affect Traffic Fatalaties,” Jed Kolko, Public Policy Institute of California).
“Today, cell phones are an integral part of our daily lives. They provide an instant connection to family, friends and business contacts,” observed Councilman Bill Green. “Unfortunately, the simple act of dialing a phone number or sending a text message while driving can turn a trip to the grocery store into a trip to the emergency room.”
“By requiring the usage of hands-free devices, we expect to see a significant reduction in the number of accidents. The purpose of this law is to not only educate the public about the dangers associated with cell phone usage, but to effect a change in behavior,” explained Councilman Green. “We’d like to see drivers talk less behind the wheel and give their full attention to operating their vehicles.”
To date, every G7 country except for the United States has banned non-hands free mobile usage while driving. In the United States, New York, New Jersey, the District of Columbia, California and Washington, as well as a number of municipalities in Pennsylvania, have enacted hands-free laws.
Green and Greenlee’s legislation is modeled on similar laws passed around the country. Councilman Greenlee explained, “The legislation is still being fine-tuned to ensure that it is an appropriate fit for the City of Philadelphia.” In addition to requiring hands free devices, the bill would ban text messaging and web surfing. “For obvious reasons, emergency-phone calls are exempt from the restriction,” added Councilman Greenlee.
Councilmen Green and Greenlee will introduce the legislation when City Council returns from its summer recess, on September 18, 2008. Public hearings on the legislation will be held this fall.











I like the idea...
... but studies have suggested that the main problem w/cell phones is the distraction, not the physical act of holding a phone. In other words, even drivers using hands-free phones are distracted when compared to drivers not using any sort of phone.
Of course, there are many distractions other than cell phones- kids, conversation, changing radio stations or CDs, etc. Cell phone users are an easy target, to be sure, but hardly the only one.
I'm just sayin',
-Z
True, but...
The act of dialing a phone and looking at buttons/contact or searching for a phone can be more distracting. If I gave myself a dime every time I saw someone holding a phone and not attentive to the road and their surroundings (especially those getting directions and stopping/starting/weaving a lot) I'd be a rich man. I saw someone holding a phone this morning zooming up 18th near CCP going in excess of 45mph.
Obama 2008
The law in NJ works
I have no idea about the rates of crashing or anything like that. (And, of course, we don't particularly have the power to deal with the motor vehicle code in Philly, but, that is another issue.)
But... as someone who spent the last year commuting to, and driving around in, Central NJ, the law makes a difference in driving behavior. In March, when NJ first actually started enforcing it, it was crazy to see people actually pulled over on their cell phone. I know that I would keep of my phone until I got back in PA.