An Evening at the Inquirer's Great Expectation Project: Just Maybe Some Hope

Tuesday evening, I attended the Inquirer’s Great Expectations Project at Holy Family University in the Northeast. For those of you are unfamiliar with the project, the Citizens' Forum is an attempt by the Inquirer and some civic partners to ensure that the upcoming Mayoral election is issue based, and somewhat more ambitiously, an attempt to allow citizens input into politics until the next mayor is elected and beyond.

Chris Satullo, Tom Ferrick and a couple of others reporters and event organizers were present, as well as an experienced team of group discussion facilitators. Mr. Satullo gave a good introduction in which he stated that the project had a bias: its organizers firmly believed Philadelphia could be the next great American city if political leaders and regional citizens make the right choices. I applaud the Inquirer for undertaking the project because it is projects like this that suggest the constructive role the media can play in society. There will be many more sessions before the end of February so please attend one of them to contribute to the conversation.

There is no doubt that the questions asked by the facilitators were difficult ones. The facilitators did their best to allow the 3 or 4 dozen attendees to share their opinions and leave feeling like they had made practical suggestions to improve Philadelphia. I co-opted my group a little to try and get away from talking about crime or public education to the extent that I could—and we’ll seem if my group’s suggestion makes it into the forum summaries.

During the evening, I was asking myself, why is Philadelphia great? Why do I want to live here? It was extremely troubling to me that the best answers had nothing to do with logic or quality of life. The truth is that the main, indeed, perhaps the only reason I’m in Philadelphia is because my family and friends are here. Yes, I do love big five basketball but aside from that I could think of few other things that I could live without.

I don’t know if it is just me at the end of a long day or what but the sense that I got from participating in the forum is that people are overwhelmed. They are fearful. They feel disconnected from City Hall and the energy that is in Center City. They are uninspired. I asked my workgroup if they knew of anyone who had ever attempted to start a business. They looked at me like I was an alien. The best strengths to build on that most individuals could think of for the city were the old standbys of quality hospitals and educational institutions. I hesitate to share too much of my experience at the event because I want you to attend and have your own experience.

What I know for certain is that Philadelphians need to be inspired; they need enthusiasm and they need a reason to trust their government. They need to know that the future is bright and twenty reasons why it is bright. They need to know that the future is worth sacrifices today. They need to be engaged and involved, and they need to be reminded that it's okay, indeed, necessary to take risks. And no 5 gazillion pound position paper on crime is going to sway their votes.

I'm optimistic about this Mayor's race because I think there are a few good candidates, maybe even one or two who are extraordinary. I'm hoping that just maybe they'll remind me of how great Philadelphia is and how much better it's going to become.

Getting inspired

Why we live here remains an interesting question. I have asked myself many times, as I scout private schools and calculate the distance between my home and the latest homicide. But I have to say that this election gives me some hope.

It was very exciting to be at the East Mt. Airy/West Mt. Airy Neighbor's association meeting Monday night, where the announced candidates (minus CF who was busy in DC) squared off in a meet the peeps/Q and A. It was quite a lovefest, as they could not keep themselves from praising each other over and over. I had several impressions I will save for another post; but I was impressed that (IMHO) both Nutter and Evans really made me feel as if there was serious hope that the positive energy of this city could be released and channeled into making it a really great place to live.

More than anything, it is simply exciting to have a mayor's race where there is widespread acknowledgment that a) it is really anyone's race to take and b) all the announced candidates are men of integrity and character. None is perfect, but it will be a true surprise if whoever is elected turns out to be a scoundrel. This was not true 8 years ago.

MDCphilly says we need to be inspired. Amen. I have not felt inspired by anyone in this city in a long time. Not even Eddie moved me. But last night, I really felt that these guys mean what they say about changing things.

I have been fooled before. I originally thought Monica Lewinsky was a deluded crackpot. But it is hard to imagine that if Knox, Evans, or Nutter gets in, that they will be able to show their faces unless they stick to some of the promises they have made so far in this campaign.

Evans promised to make it no longer the case that there is any reason to have to call a ward leader or a city council person to get services. Knox will put in place a 311 service and fire those who have a backlog of unhandled service calls. Nutter promises a "complete overhaul" of city government, and an "implosion" of L and I. (And for the record, Kerry Foster from the Greens was there too, but he was overmatched and did not say anything to make me excited about the prospect of a Green mayor) (Also for the record, I entered the room as leaning Evans and left the room a strong Nutter supporter.)

The point is that there is some hope that this election, post-pay to play scandal, post-Milton, post-airport concession thievery, might be a major turning point for the city. I did not hear Fattah; but of the three Dems I heard, I would be excited to live in a city where any of them was in charge. It will be an interesting race and and interesting 2008.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Syndicate content