Who is in charge of this mess?

Over the past few days, I’ve been watching as various candidates prepare their nomination papers and submit them to the City Commissioners. It’s been clear that the process is both cumbersome and confusing. While challengers are the ones who usually have the most trouble, Bob Brady has shown that even the most seasoned politicians can get confused.

The problem with local elections goes far beyond gathering and filing petitions. Every part of the process seems to be wrought with confusion and difficulty. How many good people have looked at this mess and decided not to seek public office? We clearly need to reform the basic way in which Philadelphia conducts its elections.

Click "Read More" for the rest......

According to the city charter, the City Commissioners are responsible for overseeing municipal elections. They test the voting machines, maintain voter databases, and oversee voter registration. As far as I can tell, they are also responsible for writing most of the forms that confuse the hell out of candidates. All of these problems should make the current commissioners think about how their office could be more responsive and transparent.

The City Commissioners have come under scrutiny before. A few years back, Ed Goppelt from HallWatch.org got into a fight with Commissioner Marge Tartaglione because she refused to provide electronic copies of polling locations. Although the information was eventually made available, it’s clear that the office can be quite resistant to reform or citizen input.

The recent problems with financial disclosure forms are just the tip of the iceberg. People concerned with the integrity and transparency of our electoral process should take this opportunity to call for major changes. While there are obviously many possible reforms, we should focus on making it easier to register to vote and run for office. Removing barriers to participation should be the top priority of city commissioners.

Who's in charge of the mess? The COMMONWEALTH OF PA.

Who's in charge of the mess? The COMMONWEALTH.

We use the state's forms - and state's process - we can't change that at a local level. Unlike campaign contribution limits, the state law definitely rules on these issues. But not without debate, of course!

WWGjr

And, the party can say that

And, the party can say that it will not support candidates who engage in the stupid challenges.

Yes, the State is in charge, and the Party has been using the confusing laws to its advantage. Now that the head of the party is going to potentially booted for this, isn't this an issue where we can all join hands, sing kumbaya, and push together for change on?

This is part of the confusion

The petitions are written by the state, but collected by the City Commissioners?

Also, I have no doubt that there are many electoral reforms that could be undertaken both at the state and local level to make it easier to run for office. Or get on the ballot. Or register to vote. I think the problem is that much of the Philadelphia political establishment has a vested interest in making it difficult for challengers and other outsiders impact the process.

---
http://benwaxman.com

County Board of Elections

The petitions are collected by the County Board of Elections.

It's a county function under state law - and Philadelphia is both city and county.

WWGjr

I believe that it should be

I believe that it should be a process to run for elected office. Being a candidate should not be like getting in line in a pizza store. Elected officials can change the face of society not just run a store or blog for a living.

The forms might be able to be adjusted for people to comprehend but like other people have agreed on, mistakes will happen on any form, as long as a reasonable person(voter) can understand it.

Whether it be the state or local, make people work to run for office. Force people to earn their stripes.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Syndicate content